Anti-Dilution Provisions Explained: Ratchet vs Average
Anti-dilution provisions explained with a worked euro down round. See how full ratchet and broad-based weighted average change who owns what, step by step.
Anti-dilution provisions protect an investor when the company later sells shares at a lower price than the investor paid. They work by adjusting the price at which the investor's preferred shares convert into common shares, so the investor ends up with more shares.
Founders pay for that protection, because the extra shares come out of everyone else's percentage. This guide explains the two main types, full ratchet and weighted average, and then works through one down round (a round at a lower valuation than the one before) step by step, with the formula and every number.
Anti-dilution provisions explained: what they protect
When a company issues new shares, existing holders own a smaller percentage. That is normal dilution, and our guide to equity dilution shows how it works. Normal dilution is the price of growth, and most investors accept it as long as the share price rises.
A down round is different, because the new shares are sold at a lower price than earlier investors paid. The earlier investor's shares are now worth less per share, and the investor also holds a smaller percentage. An anti-dilution provision gives the earlier investor some compensation for the lower price.
The compensation is built into the conversion price. Preferred shares can be converted into common shares at a stated ratio. The original ratio is usually one to one, and it is set by dividing the price paid per preferred share by the conversion price. Lower the conversion price and each preferred share turns into more common shares. A law-firm guide from Osborne Clarke, a European law firm, describes the same idea: the investor receives additional shares to make up for the lower price of the new round.
The two main types
Full ratchet
Full ratchet resets the earlier investor's conversion price to the price of the new round, whatever the size of the new round. Osborne Clarke calls it the most investor-friendly form of protection and the most dilutive for founders and other ordinary shareholders. A tiny sale of shares at a low price is enough to reprice the whole earlier investment.
Weighted average
Weighted average adjusts the conversion price by a smaller amount that depends on how many shares are sold in the down round. A small sale at a low price moves the price only a little. A large sale at a low price moves it more. The model term sheet from the US National Venture Capital Association uses this formula.
CP2 = CP1 × (A + B) ÷ (A + C)
- CP2 is the new conversion price after the down round.
- CP1 is the conversion price before it.
- A is the number of shares counted as outstanding before the new issue. In the model term sheet this includes all common shares, all preferred shares on an as-converted basis and all outstanding options on an as-exercised basis. This is the "broad-based" version.
- B is the money the company receives in the new issue, divided by CP1. It is the number of shares the new money would have bought at the old price.
- C is the number of shares actually issued in the new round.
In a "narrow-based" version, A counts fewer shares, for example only outstanding shares and not options. Osborne Clarke notes that the broad-based version is less dilutive for ordinary shareholders than the narrow-based one, because a larger A makes the adjustment smaller.
Worked example: one down round, three outcomes
Example. A company has 4,000,000 founder shares and 500,000 options. A venture investor bought 1,000,000 Series A preferred shares for €2,000,000, which is €2.00 per share. Before any new round, the fully diluted share count is 4,000,000 + 500,000 + 1,000,000 = 5,500,000. The founders own 4,000,000 ÷ 5,500,000 = 72.73 percent, the investor owns 1,000,000 ÷ 5,500,000 = 18.18 percent and the options are 9.09 percent.
The company then raises a Series B round of €1,000,000 at €1.00 per share, half the Series A price. It issues 1,000,000 new shares. To keep the example simple, we hold the Series B share count fixed at 1,000,000 and ask what the Series A protection does to everyone else.
Outcome 1: no anti-dilution protection
The Series A conversion price stays at €2.00. Each preferred share still converts into one common share. The total is 5,500,000 + 1,000,000 = 6,500,000 shares, and the investor owns 1,000,000 ÷ 6,500,000 = 15.38 percent.
Outcome 2: broad-based weighted average, every step
- CP1 is €2.00.
- A is 5,500,000, which is every share and option counted before the round.
- B is the new money divided by CP1, which is €1,000,000 ÷ €2.00 = 500,000.
- C is the number of shares issued, which is 1,000,000.
- CP2 = €2.00 × (5,500,000 + 500,000) ÷ (5,500,000 + 1,000,000) = €2.00 × 6,000,000 ÷ 6,500,000 = €1.846.
- The conversion ratio is €2.00 ÷ €1.846 = 1.0833, so the investor's 1,000,000 preferred shares convert into 1,000,000 × 1.0833 = 1,083,333 common shares. That is 83,333 more than before.
- The total is 4,000,000 + 500,000 + 1,083,333 + 1,000,000 = 6,583,333 shares. The investor owns 1,083,333 ÷ 6,583,333 = 16.46 percent.
Outcome 3: full ratchet
- The new price is €1.00, so CP2 = €1.00.
- The conversion ratio is €2.00 ÷ €1.00 = 2, so the investor's 1,000,000 preferred shares convert into 2,000,000 common shares.
- The total is 4,000,000 + 500,000 + 2,000,000 + 1,000,000 = 7,500,000 shares. The investor owns 2,000,000 ÷ 7,500,000 = 26.67 percent.
| Holder | No protection | Broad-based weighted average | Full ratchet |
|---|---|---|---|
| Founders | 61.54% | 60.76% | 53.33% |
| Series A investor | 15.38% | 16.46% | 26.67% |
| Options | 7.69% | 7.59% | 6.67% |
| Series B investor | 15.38% | 15.19% | 13.33% |
| Total shares | 6,500,000 | 6,583,333 | 7,500,000 |
The founders started at 72.73 percent. With no protection they fall to 61.54 percent, with weighted average to 60.76 percent and with full ratchet to 53.33 percent. Weighted average takes about 0.8 percentage points from the founders in this example, and full ratchet takes about 8.2 percentage points. The investor in the Series B round also loses ground. In real deals, new investors often insist on a fixed percentage, so the extra anti-dilution shares fall even more heavily on the founders. Check this with your lawyer.
When the protection is triggered, and when it is not
The formula applies only when the company issues new securities at a price below the current conversion price. The model term sheet also lists customary exceptions where the adjustment does not apply. They include shares issued on conversion of the preferred shares, shares from a stock split or stock dividend, shares issued on conversion of other convertible securities, and shares or options issued to employees, directors and consultants under a plan approved by the board.
That last exception is why a well-run option pool does not trigger the protection each time you grant options. Read the exceptions list in your own documents, because a short list makes the protection trigger more often.
How to handle anti-dilution in a negotiation
- Ask for broad-based weighted average. It is the version in the model term sheet and it is the gentlest of the formulas shown here.
- Say no to full ratchet if you can. The example shows what it costs.
- Check the definition of A. A narrow base makes the adjustment larger.
- Check the exceptions. Make sure employee options and conversions of earlier instruments are excluded.
- Look for a pay-to-play clause. The model term sheet has an optional pay-to-play term, under which an investor who does not buy its share of a later down round has its preferred shares converted into common shares and loses the related rights. See our guide to pro rata rights for how the share-buying right works.
The best protection against triggering any of this is to avoid a round at a lower price. Our guide to the down round covers what causes one and what founders can do.
Frequently asked questions
What is the difference between full ratchet and weighted average anti-dilution?
Full ratchet resets the earlier investor's conversion price to the new, lower price. Weighted average moves the price by an amount that depends on how many shares are sold and at what price. In the example above, full ratchet gave the investor 2,000,000 shares and weighted average gave 1,083,333.
What is broad-based weighted average anti-dilution?
It is the weighted average formula with a wide definition of A, the number of shares counted before the round. Broad-based counts common shares, preferred shares on an as-converted basis and options. A wider count gives a smaller adjustment than a narrow one.
Does anti-dilution protect founders?
No. It protects investors who hold preferred shares with the right. Founders hold common shares, which have no adjustment, so the extra shares given to the investor reduce the founders' percentage.
Does anti-dilution apply to a normal funding round at a higher price?
No. The adjustment applies only when new shares are issued at a price below the current conversion price. A round at a higher price causes ordinary dilution, which has no compensation.
Do anti-dilution provisions exist outside the US?
The mechanics are the same wherever they are used, and a European law firm describes both the full ratchet and the weighted average. The exact wording and how it is enforced depend on your country's company law, so ask a local lawyer.
This is general education, not legal or tax advice. Instrument names, tax treatment of equity and the formalities of issuing shares differ by country. Check the details with a lawyer where your company is registered.
FIKR Cap is the cap table tool we are building at FIKR. Join the waiting list.