Home/Blog/Scorecards/Choose Scorecard Pillars and Bands: A Pr…
Scorecards

Choose Scorecard Pillars and Bands: A Practical Method

How to choose scorecard pillars and bands: let the grid you are willing to write set the counts, and give each band a follow-up unlike its neighbour's.

Cover of the FIKR Space guide: Choose Scorecard Pillars and Bands: A Practical Method

To choose scorecard pillars and bands, start from the grid you are willing to write rather than the structure that looks tidy, then keep a band only if it would trigger a different follow-up from its neighbour. Counts come from the writing bill and from consequences, not from taste.

Pillars and bands feel like design decisions, so people pick them early and by feel: five of each because it sounds balanced, or seven pillars because the topic seems to have seven parts. The cost arrives later. This post gives a way to settle both numbers with arithmetic and a simple test instead. For the wider picture of what you are building, see how to build a scorecard.

How to choose scorecard pillars and bands from the grid

Every respondent ends up at a coordinate: a pillar and a band. Each coordinate needs its own narrative and a few actions. So the number of pillars multiplied by the number of bands is the number of pieces of writing you owe. That figure should drive your choice, not follow from it.

The working method has four steps:

  1. Decide how many cells you can honestly write well. Be realistic about your time.
  2. Find pairs of pillar and band counts whose product fits inside that number.
  3. Pick the pair that matches your topic, with fewer pillars before fewer bands, or the reverse, depending on where your expertise is deepest.
  4. Write the number of cells down and keep it where you will see it.

The guide's own arithmetic shows how fast the total grows. A grid of five pillars by five bands is twenty-five narratives. Seven by five is thirty-five. Eight by seven is fifty-six, and that is a size most people abandon, usually after they have written all the questions.

If you can writeYou could buildWatch out for
About twenty-five cellsFive pillars by five bandsUneven quality in the cells nobody reads
About thirty-five cellsSeven pillars by five bandsPillars that overlap each other
About fifty cells or moreProbably nothing of that sizeA half-written grid that never ships

Pillars: how many, and what they are for

A pillar is one dimension the result reports on separately. It earns its place when it produces its own advice, and when the answers to it differ from the answers to every other pillar.

Size gives a rough guide. A short lead magnet tends to carry between one and six pillars. A long paid diagnostic tends to carry between five and seven. These ranges describe what holds together in practice, not a law, but they are a useful check when your own count lands far outside them.

Two tests keep pillars honest:

  • The distinctness test. If the same pillar turns out to be the weakest for most respondents, the scorecard is really a single-topic diagnostic wearing several hats, and some of your pillars are probably measuring the same underlying thing. That is a design finding, and you read it from real data once you have it. The method is in how to calibrate a scorecard.
  • The advice test. Can you describe what you would tell someone who is weak on this pillar and different from what you would tell them for a neighbouring pillar? If not, merge the two.

Name pillars so they read as chapter titles for the reader. They are printed above the questions, and they are the headings people see in their results.

Free guide, 39 pages: The Scorecard Playbook. Send me the guide.

Bands: the follow-up test

A band exists to cause something different to happen. The cleanest way to find out how many you need is to write the follow-up for each band before you write any questions. Take a piece of paper and draw a line for every band you are considering. Beside each, write what that person receives next.

Now compare neighbours. If two bands would receive the same message, the same offer and the same next step, you do not have two bands. You have one. Merge them and you save a whole column of narratives.

CheckResultAction
Two adjacent bands get the same follow-upOne of them is decorationMerge them
A band has no follow-up at allNothing happens for those peopleWrite one or remove the band
Every band has a distinct follow-upThe ladder is doing real workKeep the count

This is why the guide says scorecard design is segment design. A band is a segment you can act on. If you cannot act differently on it, it is not a segment, no matter how neat it looks on the results page. How the follow-up is wired to each band is covered in how to write a scorecard action plan.

Check that every band is a believable place to be

A ladder can pass the follow-up test and still fail on the respondent's side. Read the bands from top to bottom as a person who might land in each one. The lowest should be uncomfortable and specific. The highest should still leave something to do. If the instrument flatters everyone, it is worthless, so at least one band has to say something unwelcome and true.

Also check that the number of bands suits how finely your questions can separate people. A short lead magnet with few questions cannot place people reliably into many narrow bands. If you find yourself wanting a seventh band from a small question set, the better answer is fewer bands.

A worked comparison of two choices

Imagine two plans for the same subject. The first has seven pillars and seven bands, because the topic seems rich and finer detail seems helpful. That is forty-nine cells before you count the actions. The second has five pillars and five bands, which is twenty-five cells.

The second plan almost always produces the better product, for a plain reason: the writer has time to say something specific in every cell. In the first plan, effort thins out as the project drags, and the cells that nobody tests are written last and written worst. A smaller grid with sharper copy beats a larger grid with filler.

Which cells matter most

Because a results page sorts pillars weakest first and flags the top one as the place to start, the weakest pillar's cell is the one a respondent reads. If you must make trade-offs, plan to write those cells with the most care. When you choose the size of the grid, count how many of those high-attention cells it creates. A five by five grid has five such cells, one for each band. That is a manageable amount of your best writing.

FIKR Score, diagnostics that qualify: turn your audience questions into a quiz that finds buyers. See FIKR Score.

What to do when your topic really is large

Some subjects feel too big for a small grid. The answer is not to expand the grid, it is to choose what this instrument is for. If the topic has many parts, ask which few parts matter most to the person taking it, and build around those. A longer treatment is what a paid diagnostic is for, and that is a different product with a different job. Mixing the two ends in the middle ground that suits neither.

Once pillars and bands are fixed, the next decisions are mechanical. How scores are calculated across pillars is in how to weight scorecard questions, and where one band ends and the next begins is in how to set scorecard band boundaries.

Mistakes that show up at this stage

  • Counting pillars by topic, not by advice. A subject may have many parts, but a pillar only earns its place if it leads to advice that the others do not give.
  • Adding a band to feel generous. An extra band that flatters people lowers the value of every band above it.
  • Discovering the bill late. Choosing the structure first and learning the writing cost afterwards is the pattern behind failed projects, and it is avoidable with one multiplication.
  • Treating the count as final too early. Real respondents will show you where pillars overlap, so leave room to merge them before launch.
Free guide, 39 pages: The Scorecard Playbook. Send me the guide.

A short checklist before you move on

  • I have written down pillars multiplied by bands, and I accept the number.
  • Every pillar would produce advice that no other pillar gives.
  • Every band has a follow-up that differs from the band next to it.
  • At least one band says something uncomfortable and true.
  • The audience is narrow enough for "others like you" to be a fair phrase.

When all five lines can be ticked, you have a grid worth filling. If one cannot, fix it now, while changing the plan costs an edit and not a rewrite.

FIKR Score, diagnostics that qualify: turn your audience questions into a quiz that finds buyers. See FIKR Score.

Frequently asked questions

Is it better to have more pillars or more bands?

Neither is better in itself. What matters is the product of the two, because that is the amount of writing, and whether each pillar and each band changes what the person is told. Fewer, sharper choices usually beat more.

Can I change the number of bands after launch?

You can, but it is an edit to a live instrument, and nothing recomputes the results people already received. Treat it as a new version of the scorecard and settle the count before you drive traffic.

What if two pillars always score the same?

They may be measuring the same thing. Compare the answers, and if they move together, merge the pillars or add harder questions that force them apart.

Do I need the same number of actions in every cell?

The guide suggests budgeting roughly four actions per cell, and its range is between three and five. Consistency matters less than making each action specific and ordered.

The full method, with the checklists, is in The Scorecard Playbook, a free 39-page playbook.

LG

Luis Goncalves

// Founder & CEO at FIKR Space

Three-time founder. Built and exited Evolution4All before this. Now building FIKR Space — the operating infrastructure underneath every innovation ecosystem (startups, accelerators, governments, investors). Lisbon-based, works global.

Claim your founding member spot.

Every founding member is hand-reviewed. Tell us who you are and how you want to co-create — we get back inside 48 hours.

Role
Job Title
Country
Cookies

We use cookies.

Essential ones keep the site working. The rest only run if you say so. No dark patterns, no pre-ticked boxes.Privacy policy

Co-create with us. It's about building it together.Co-Create With Us