Home/Blog/Startup Exits/Decide What a Good Exit Is for You: Set …
Startup Exits

Decide What a Good Exit Is for You: Set the Number First

How to decide what a good exit is for you: put the outcome in a number, set the conditions, price the distraction and fix your walk away point before any offer.

Cover of the FIKR Space guide: Decide What a Good Exit Is for You: Set the Number First

How to decide what a good exit is for you: work out the outcome that would be good for you specifically, in a number, before anyone makes an offer. After an offer exists the pressure runs entirely towards accepting it, so the thinking has to come first.

This is general education and not personal financial or legal advice. Your own number is your decision.

How to decide what a good exit is for you: start with whose outcome it is

Founders, early employees and investors want materially different things from the same transaction, and those interests diverge sharply at lower prices. An offer that returns capital to investors and pays founders modestly may be perfectly acceptable to a fund with a portfolio. It may be unacceptable to a founder with seven years invested.

So the first step is to stop asking whether a deal is good in general. Ask whether it is good for you. That question has an answer only if you have written down what you would need, and the answer comes in the form of a number.

PartyWhat a given offer may mean
An investor with a portfolioCapital returned may be an acceptable result
A founder with years investedThe same offer paying modestly may not be
An early employeeDepends on exercise terms, acceleration and what they actually net

The interests are not villainous. They simply differ, and they differ most at the prices that are most likely. That is why the arithmetic in how to run an exit waterfall belongs before this decision and not after it.

Know your waterfall before you know your price

This ordering is the part founders get wrong. Understand what the preference stack does at a range of prices first, and only then think about what price you would want. If you do it the other way round, you anchor on a headline figure, work backwards, and discover late that the number you had in mind produces an outcome you would not accept.

The waterfall is the constraint and the price is the variable. A good number for you is one that you have tested against your actual documents, at a disappointing price, a plausible price and a good price. Without that, a target is a hope with a figure attached.

Free guide, 32 pages: The Exit Playbook. Send me the guide.

Turn the ambition into conditions

Rather than a target date, define the conditions. The guide's suggestion is to say what would need to be true, and then treat that as a roadmap.

  • A level of revenue you would want to have reached.
  • A quality of retention you would want to see.
  • A reduction in customer concentration.
  • A degree of independence from you.

This converts an ambition into a set of things to work on. Most of them make the company better regardless of whether an exit ever happens, which is the correct test for any exit preparation work. If a task would only make sense in the event of a sale, be suspicious of it. If it would improve the company on an ordinary Tuesday, do it.

Different buyers are different transactions

What counts as good also depends on who is on the other side. A strategic acquirer buying capability, a competitor buying market share, a financial buyer underwriting cash flows, an acquihire buying the team and an asset sale buying the technology have different valuation logic, different terms and different treatment of the team. The difference for common shareholders can be large.

Knowing which type of conversation you are in tells you what is actually being valued and what is negotiable. Assuming all acquisitions are the same transaction is how founders optimise for the wrong things throughout a process. A comparison of two of the main types is in strategic acquirer versus financial buyer.

Price the distraction honestly

Serious conversations consume the founder for months. If the business is at a delicate stage, engaging may cost more than the option is worth, and it is legitimate to decline to start a process on those grounds alone.

Decide in advance what would make it worth engaging, so that flattering interest does not pull you into months of work that was never likely to conclude. The guide calls this a common and expensive pattern, particularly when a large acquirer's corporate development team is exploring the market rather than buying.

Question to answer in advanceWhy it protects you
What would make a conversation worth my attention?Flattering interest does not set the agenda
Is the business at a delicate stage?Engaging may cost more than the option is worth
Who would run the company while I am absorbed?A dip in performance is the most common deal killer
Is the other side buying or exploring?Exploring can consume months and conclude nothing

What a process does to the company is covered in how to prepare for acquisition due diligence.

Write down what would make you walk away

The guide's process checklist includes a line that is easy to skip: know what would make you walk away, written down before the first meeting. A walk away point written in advance is a commitment made while calm. A walk away point invented mid process is a negotiation with yourself under pressure.

Put it next to the outcome that would be good, so that the two bracket your decision. Between them is the space in which you are genuinely open to talking.

FIKR Cap: see FIKR Cap.

Include the people who joined on the strength of equity

A good outcome for you is not the whole picture if people joined partly on the promise of equity. Option holders may need to exercise to participate, which can require significant cash and create a tax event at an awkward moment. Unvested equity may accelerate or may not. Someone who has already left may have an exercise window that has expired.

These outcomes are set by documents signed years earlier, and founders frequently discover the specifics only during a transaction, when there is little room to fix anything. Deciding what is acceptable for the team, and finding out early what would happen to them, is part of defining a good exit. The full treatment is in what happens to employee equity when a startup is acquired.

A worked template for your own answer

You can capture the whole decision on one page. Fill in the blanks in your own words and keep it with your cap table records. Nothing here is a recommendation about what your answers should be.

  1. The outcome that would be good for me, as a number, tested at three prices.
  2. The conditions that would need to be true for me to engage.
  3. The type of buyer I would consider, and what each would be valuing.
  4. What would make me walk away.
  5. What retention terms I would accept, and for how long.
  6. What I want for the team, and what I have found out they would net.
  7. Who would run the business if I were absorbed for months.

The retention line deserves a note. If the company cannot operate without you, an acquirer is buying an asset that depends on someone who is about to become considerably wealthier and less motivated, and that is usually priced through retention terms that tie you in for years. Decide what you would accept before you are asked. The related work is in how to reduce key person risk before an exit.

The test of whether your number is real

A number is real if it survives these checks.

  • You have run it through the preference stack at more than one price.
  • You know what employees would net at the same price.
  • You know what escrow, an earnout or stock consideration would do to the figure that arrives.
  • You have spoken to someone qualified about tax, early.

If any of those is missing, the number is a headline, and headlines are the thing this whole subject warns against. You will find what the stages between headline and bank account do in what does a startup exit actually pay.

Free guide, 32 pages: The Exit Playbook. Send me the guide.

Keep the honest limit in view

You do not control whether an exit happens. Deciding what is good is not a plan to have one, and it should not tempt you to build the company to be acquired. Buyers are drawn to companies that do not need them. The purpose of this exercise is clarity, so that if an opportunity arrives you recognise it, and if it does not, you have lost nothing and probably improved the company.

FIKR Cap: see FIKR Cap.

Frequently asked questions

Should I set a target date for an exit?

The guide suggests defining conditions instead of a date: a level of revenue, a quality of retention, a reduction in customer concentration and a degree of independence from you. Those become work to do now.

What if flattering interest arrives before I am ready?

Decide in advance what would make it worth engaging. Interest alone can pull you into months of work, especially when a large acquirer is exploring the market rather than buying.

Is it legitimate to decline a conversation?

Yes. If the business is at a delicate stage, engaging may cost more than the option is worth, and declining on those grounds alone is legitimate.

Can I rely on this to choose my number?

This is general education, not personal financial advice. Use it to structure your thinking, test the number against your actual documents, and speak to someone qualified for decisions about your own situation.

The full method, with the checklists, is in The Exit Playbook, a free 32-page playbook.

LG

Luis Goncalves

// Founder & CEO at FIKR Space

Three-time founder. Built and exited Evolution4All before this. Now building FIKR Space — the operating infrastructure underneath every innovation ecosystem (startups, accelerators, governments, investors). Lisbon-based, works global.

Claim your founding member spot.

Every founding member is hand-reviewed. Tell us who you are and how you want to co-create — we get back inside 48 hours.

Role
Job Title
Country
Cookies

We use cookies.

Essential ones keep the site working. The rest only run if you say so. No dark patterns, no pre-ticked boxes.Privacy policy

Co-create with us. It's about building it together.Co-Create With Us