How to Decide What Goes in Sales Commit, Step by Step
How to decide what goes in sales commit: write the entry rules before the review, use facts about the buyer and their date, and walk the named list every week.
To decide what goes in sales commit, write down the criteria a deal must meet before the review, then admit only the deals that meet them, named one by one. A deal belongs in commit because it qualifies, never because the number is short.
The criteria can be yours, but they must exist in writing, and they must be facts about the buyer rather than feelings about the deal.
How to decide what goes in sales commit
Commit is the list of deals you would stake your credibility on closing in this period. It is the number that answers the near-term question, and it is the one people quote when they want to know what is coming. That makes it the figure most likely to be bent, and the easiest to bend, because it has no formula behind it. It is a judgement, and judgements drift when nothing anchors them.
The anchor is a written entry rule. Most arguments about the forecast are not about deals at all. They are about two people using the word "commit" to mean different things. Writing the meaning down ends that argument before it starts.
Four criteria to start from
The guide offers four as an example of what a rule might say. A deal belongs in commit when:
- The person who signs has been in the conversation.
- The close date comes from the buyer's own process, not from your quarter end.
- The paperwork path is known.
- No unresolved objection is outstanding.
Your criteria may differ, and nothing in the method says these four are the only right ones. The point is that they exist in writing before the review. Look at what they share: every one is a fact about the buyer or about the process, and every one can be checked by someone other than the seller.
| Criterion | The question to ask | What a failure looks like |
|---|---|---|
| The signer has been in the conversation | Has the person who signs actually taken part? | You are relying on a friendly contact to carry the decision upwards |
| The date is the buyer's | Where did this close date come from? | The date is simply the end of your quarter |
| The paperwork path is known | Do we know the steps between yes and signature? | Nobody can say what happens after a verbal agreement |
| No open objection | Is anything still unresolved? | A concern was raised and never answered |
Why the close date has to be the buyer's
This criterion catches more optimism than any other. "They said they decide at the board meeting on the fourteenth" is a close date. "We need it by month end" is a wish. The first comes from the buyer's own process and can be checked. The second comes from your calendar and tells you nothing about when the buyer will act.
A related point sits underneath it. Three dates are easily confused: the day the buyer signs, the day the work starts and the day the cash arrives. Pick one for the forecast, usually the signature, and let the cash plan work out the others from your real payment terms. More on that hand-over is in how to turn a sales forecast into a cash plan.
Commit is a list, so keep it a list
Each deal in commit is named. That is what separates it from the weighted pipeline, which is an average across many deals. If you cannot say which deals make up your commit, you do not have a commit, you have a total. The contrast between the two is laid out in weighted pipeline versus commit.
Two habits protect that:
- Name large deals individually, always. A single big deal hidden inside a total can make every average meaningless.
- Keep best case separate. Best case is commit plus the deals that could close if things go well. Reporting it as commit guarantees a miss and destroys trust in later numbers.
Walk the commit every week, deal by deal
The commit is the one list you read in full each week, rather than reviewing only what changed. For each committed deal, ask four things:
- What happened this week?
- What is the next step, and what is its date?
- Is the close date still the buyer's?
- Does the deal still meet the commit criteria?
The most useful question is not "is this still on". The answer to that is always yes. Ask instead: what would have to go wrong for this to slip, and have we checked? That turns a ritual of reassurance into a search for the weak point.
Take deals out in the meeting, not at quarter end
A deal that no longer meets the criteria should leave commit in the meeting, on the day it fails. Waiting until the end of the quarter to remove it means the forecast carried a deal everyone knew was wrong. The cost is not the one deal. It is that the reader of the number learns the commit is padded.
The same goes for dates. A deal whose close date has moved should be tested against the rules, and the usual rule is mechanical: a deal whose close date moves twice leaves commit until something new and factual happens. How that rule works and what to do with a deal that has gone quiet is the subject of how to handle slipping deals.
Signs your commit has become a feeling
Commit goes wrong in a few recognisable ways.
| Symptom | What is probably happening |
|---|---|
| Deals appear in commit near the end of the period to reach the number | The entry rule is being bent to fit the target |
| Commit is hit exactly, every quarter | Good deals are being held back rather than forecast |
| Closings pile up in the final days of the period | The forecast no longer follows the deals |
| A deal stays in commit through repeated date changes | The slip rule is not being applied |
The second row surprises people. A perfect record sounds like good news, but a commit that is hit exactly, every quarter, usually means the commit is being managed towards the result, not forecast. A genuine forecast misses sometimes, in a direction you can measure.
Putting the rule on one page
A rule nobody can find is not a rule. Before the next review, write the commit definition on a single page that the whole team can see, and make sure it answers these points.
- What facts about the buyer must be true before a deal enters commit.
- Whose date counts as the close date, and which date the forecast uses: signature, start of work or cash arriving.
- What makes a deal leave commit, including what happens when its date moves.
- Which decisions are allowed to rely on commit, and which are not.
The last point connects the list to the rest of the company. A hire, which is a long and expensive commitment, should be justified by contracted revenue plus commit, never by best case. Deciding that while calm is what stops a strong pipeline week from producing an offer letter the cash cannot support.
When the number is short
Sooner or later you will hold a review where the commit falls short of what the company wants. That moment is the real test of the rule. The temptation is to find a deal that is nearly qualified and promote it, or to stretch a close date into the period.
Resist it, and treat the shortfall as information. A commit that falls short is telling you something: either the period will be tight, or the pipeline entering now is thinner than it should be. Both are things you want to know early. The first lets you adjust spending before the cash is committed. The second is an early warning for the following period, and it is a marketing and outbound problem today rather than a sales problem in three months.
A short commit that is honest is worth more than a full one that is not, because only the honest one can be steered by.
Make it safe to be accurate
People enter and remove deals according to what they think the meeting rewards. If a missed commit is punished and an inflated one is praised, some will pad the list with hope and others will hide good deals until they are certain, so that they never miss. Both distort the number the company steers by. Praise accurate calls, including accurate bad news, and keep the conversation about deals rather than about people.
Check the commit against what happened
The only way to know if your criteria are good is to compare commit with what actually closed, every quarter, and to write down the gap. If commit runs consistently over, tighten the criteria. If it runs consistently under, you may be holding back deals that qualify. The comparison itself is described in how to calibrate a sales forecast.
Frequently asked questions
Who decides whether a deal is in commit?
The written criteria decide. The person closest to a deal is the person least able to judge it, so the question is whether the deal meets the rule, not whether its owner feels confident.
Can a deal be in commit and also in best case?
Best case is commit plus the extra deals that could close if things go well, so commit is contained within it. Report them as separate figures and do not let either stand in for the other.
What if my quarter end is the real deadline?
Your deadline is a wish. Use the buyer's date in the forecast. If the buyer has not given one, the deal does not yet meet the criteria.
Should I change the criteria if they keep excluding deals?
Only after comparing commit with what actually closed. The criteria are yours to adjust, but adjust them from outcomes, not to make the number look better.
The full method, with the checklists, is in The Sales Forecast Playbook, a free 33-page playbook.