How to Decide Who Gets Credit and Who Pays First
How to decide who gets credit: treat a large invoice like a loan, run a minimal check on bigger customers, and let payment history guide who you pursue.
To decide who gets credit, treat every invoice on payment terms as a small loan, run a minimal check on the larger ones, and let each customer's payment behaviour show you which relationships are worth more of your time. You would not lend a significant sum to a stranger after a good meeting, and a large invoice on thirty-day terms is exactly that.
Most founders extend credit to everyone by default, because declining feels rude. This post argues for the opposite habit: a short, deliberate decision before the work starts, and an honest look afterwards at what your customers' behaviour has told you.
How to decide who gets credit: start with the loan
When you invoice for payment after delivery, you have extended credit. The customer holds your work, and you hold a promise. For the length of the terms you are their lender, usually without interest and often without noticing.
That framing changes the question. You are no longer asking whether to send an invoice. You are asking whether you would lend this amount to this customer for this long. Put that way, the answer is not always yes, and it should not be the same for a known, reliable customer as for someone you have just met. The terms themselves are settled in how to set payment terms, so here the focus is the customer.
The minimal check for larger customers
For anything material, the guide recommends a minimal check. It asks three questions.
| Question | What you are trying to learn |
|---|---|
| Are they solvent? | Whether they can pay at all |
| Do they have a payment reputation? | Whether others have found them reliable |
| Is the entity signing the same entity that will pay? | Whether the promise comes from the right party |
Nothing here calls for a specialist. The guide notes that, for a small company, a single large unpaid invoice can be existential, and that the check which would have prevented it takes twenty minutes. That is an extremely good trade.
Why the signing entity matters
The third question is the one people forget. A customer may sign through one company and expect another to pay, or invoices may name a different entity from the contract. When that happens, the party you checked is not the party you are chasing.
The guide includes this directly in its checklist: the entity being invoiced is the entity that signed. It is a small line with a large consequence, and it connects to the practical details of how to invoice correctly.
Set a ceiling for each customer
Alongside the check, decide the maximum exposure you are willing to carry with any one customer. This is a limit on the total amount outstanding, not on a single invoice.
The reason is that exposure builds up quietly. A relationship that began small can grow, invoice by invoice, into something you would never have approved in one step. A ceiling gives you a moment to pause and look again, before the position becomes the sort that threatens the business.
What to do with customers you cannot assess
Sometimes the check is not possible, or the answers are thin. In that case do not extend the same credit you would give a known customer. Decide beforehand what you require from customers you know nothing about.
The simplest tool is to move the funding of the work to them, with a payment before or during the job. That approach is the subject of how to ask for a deposit. Credit is a privilege that a customer earns through behaviour, and until you have seen some, asking for money earlier is a sensible default.
Persistent late payers need a policy
Some customers will always pay late. The guide's advice is to decide what that means before you are in the situation. The options are shorter terms at renewal, payment in advance, a price that reflects the financing cost, or declining to continue.
Having a policy matters for a practical reason. It turns an emotional conversation into a commercial one. You can say something specific about your rule for accounts with a particular payment history, and it will not sound like a personal judgement.
- Shorter terms when the account renews.
- Payment in advance for accounts with a late history.
- A price that includes the cost of financing them.
- Declining to continue, when none of the above is acceptable.
Whichever option you choose, apply it. The guide's monthly checklist asks whether the late payers policy has been applied, not merely written. The day-to-day handling of a particular late account is in how to handle a late paying customer.
Collections tells you which customers are worth having
This is the most useful idea in this part of the guide. Payment behaviour is one of the clearest signals available about a customer relationship. It tells you something no sales conversation can.
Chronic late payment often accompanies other patterns: excessive support demand, scope creep and the loudest complaints. A customer who is hard to collect from is frequently hard in other ways too. Tracking who pays how quickly gives you an unusually honest view of account quality.
Compare revenue by how it arrives
The guide makes a comparison most companies never make. Revenue from a customer who pays at a hundred and twenty days is worth materially less than the same revenue from one who pays at fifteen. The invoice totals are identical, but the cost of waiting is not.
| Customer pays | What it means for you |
|---|---|
| Quickly | The revenue funds itself and needs little follow-up |
| Slowly | You finance them for longer and chase them more |
| Slowly and with other difficulties | The account may cost more than its revenue suggests |
Use this when deciding where to put your effort. It should influence which customers you pursue more of, and which you offer shorter terms to. The number that summarises how fast you are paid overall is explained in what the collection period is.
Make it a routine, not a mood
None of this requires cold treatment of customers. It requires a routine that applies the same questions every time.
- For any material amount, run the minimal check before work begins.
- Confirm that the signing entity is the paying entity.
- Compare the exposure with the ceiling you set.
- For unknown customers, ask for money earlier.
- Review who pays late and apply your policy.
- Let the pattern shape where you pursue more business.
What a good credit decision looks like
A good decision does not need to be complicated. It is one you can explain in a sentence, made before the work and recorded afterwards. You can say what you checked, what you decided and what limit you set.
Think of it as the opposite of a reflex. The reflex is to say yes to every customer and to chase later if needed. The decision is to look at the amount, the customer and the history, and to choose the terms that fit. Both feel fast, but only one of them protects a small company from a single large unpaid invoice.
Different customers, different answers
| Customer | A sensible starting point |
|---|---|
| Known, with a record of paying promptly | Your standard terms |
| Larger, with a material invoice | The minimal check, then your standard terms or a deposit |
| Unknown | Money before or during the work |
| A persistent late payer | Your policy: shorter terms, advance payment, a financing price or no renewal |
These are starting points, not rules. The guide leaves the details to you, and asks only that the decision be deliberate.
Use what you learn
Every customer teaches you something about how they pay. If you record it, your next decision is better than your last. Over a year, a simple list of who pays quickly and who does not becomes one of the most useful records you hold.
It also helps with an uncomfortable question: which customers should you try to win more of? If the quickest payers also have the fewest other difficulties, the pattern points towards the kind of customer your company is best placed to serve.
Frequently asked questions
Is declining credit rude?
It does not have to be. Extending credit is a lending decision, and asking for payment earlier from a customer you know nothing about is a sensible, ordinary condition.
What does the minimal check involve?
Whether the customer is solvent, whether they have a payment reputation, and whether the entity signing is the one that will pay. The guide says it takes about twenty minutes.
Should I stop working with customers who pay late?
That depends on your policy. The options are shorter terms, payment in advance, a price that reflects financing cost, or declining to continue, and the choice should be made before you are in the situation.
Why does payment speed affect customer quality?
Because slow payment often comes with other patterns such as heavy support demand and scope creep. Tracking who pays how quickly gives you an honest view of the relationship.
The full method, with the checklists, is in The Getting Paid Playbook, a free 34-page playbook.