How to Make Your First Hire: Why the First Ten Matter
How to make your first hire: settle the need, the economics and the bar before you open the role, then accept that one of the first ten will still go wrong.
To make your first hire well, decide what the role is for, what it costs in months of runway and what a clear yes and a clear no look like, all before you meet a single candidate. The interview is the visible part of hiring. The decisions around it are where most of the outcome is settled.
The first ten people are among the highest-leverage decisions a founder makes, and they are almost always made with the least process. There is a pressing need, someone reasonable appears, the conversation goes well and an offer follows. Nobody wrote down what the role was for, nobody agreed what a no would look like and nobody priced the hire in the currency the company is actually short of.
How to make your first hire when each one is a tenth of the company
Hiring at ten people is structurally different from hiring at a hundred. Each of the first ten is a tenth of your culture, and culture at this size is not a values document. It is simply the behaviour of the people present, and you chose every one of them.
That is why practices borrowed from a larger company so often disappoint. Those practices assume an existing culture that will do the correcting. Here there is none. You are the correcting mechanism, and you also have a company to run.
There is a second difference, which is easy to miss. Most founders treat hiring as an evaluation problem: how do I assess this person? At this stage it is at least equally a selling problem. You are asking someone to take real career risk to join something unproven, usually for less cash than they could earn elsewhere, and the people most worth having are the ones with the most alternatives.
Six reasons the early hires carry so much weight
Early hiring deserves disproportionate attention because of specific effects that only operate at this size. None of them is the general claim that people are your greatest asset.
| Effect | What it means in practice |
|---|---|
| Each hire is a large fraction of the whole | One person is a tenth of your behaviour, standards and atmosphere, and nobody can be quietly routed around |
| They set the bar | They interview, refer former colleagues and show daily what standard of work passes |
| A weak hire costs far more than the salary | Founder attention, rework, strong people recalibrating and the months before you accept what you already knew |
| The order decides what the company can do | The sequence of roles is a strategy decision disguised as a staffing one |
| They test whether you can delegate | A capable senior person soon notices if you keep every decision |
| They become your employer story | Reputation at this size is entirely word of mouth |
Read down the right-hand column and a pattern appears. Almost every cost is invisible in the quarter you make the decision and visible only later, and by then it is hard to trace back to its source.
The compounding effect you cannot see
The most consequential of these effects is how early hires shape who comes next. Excellent people generally recommend excellent people and are uncomfortable when standards slip. Mediocre hires tend to recommend people like themselves and are relieved when the bar is low.
You will see the effect of your third hire in the quality of your twentieth, and you will not be able to trace it back. This is the reason a careful process is cheap by comparison. The cost of going slowly is small and visible. The cost of going quickly and hopefully is large and delayed.
What to settle before you open the role
The role is largely decided before anyone is interviewed. The decisions take a morning and prevent most of the expensive outcomes. Each one has its own post, and together they form a short sequence.
- The need. Write down the single thing most limiting the company this quarter, and ask whether a hire is really the way to remove it. Who to hire first at a startup covers how to choose.
- The definition. Describe what must be true after ninety days if the hire goes well. How to write a ninety day role outcome walks through it.
- The type. Say whether the role is for a generalist or a specialist, and price it in months of runway. Generalist vs specialist hire explains the trade.
- The bar. Write what a clear yes and a clear no look like, and agree that ambiguity means no.
The fourth item deserves a word here, since it sits in no sibling post by itself. Define the bar before you have met a likeable person, because afterwards your standard will move without you noticing. This is not a flaw of character. It is how anyone's judgement behaves under time pressure and social pleasantness.
Why ambiguity should mean no
Founders often feel that a candidate who is almost right is worth a try. At this size, a hire you are unsure about is a hire you will be unsure about for a year. The cost of waiting for a clearer yes is almost always lower than the cost of unwinding a doubtful one.
The rule is easiest to keep when someone else holds a copy of it. A written bar, agreed before the first conversation and shared with another person, is the only reliable defence against the warmth of a good meeting.
Running the process once the role is real
With the role defined, the process matters. Interviews are weak predictors of performance and everybody knows it, yet most early hiring is nothing but interviews. A modest amount of structure does far more than a large amount of intuition.
- A small, real and paid task shows how someone works. The process steps are covered in later posts.
- Speed is one of the few advantages a small company has. See how to hire fast as a startup.
- Selling honestly, including the parts that are hard, filters out people who would have left in the second month.
None of this requires special software. It requires deciding the steps in advance and keeping to them while you are also running the company.
After the yes
The offer is the midpoint, not the end. Whether a hire works is decided largely in the weeks after they arrive, and it is the part founders most consistently neglect, because the urgent problem of the empty seat appears to have been solved.
A new person with no context, no clear first task and nobody paying attention will spend the first two weeks anxious and unproductive. Some never fully recover. An hour of preparation before they arrive is worth weeks afterwards.
When a hire is not working, the instinct is to wait. The cost of waiting falls on the person, on the team and on you. How to tell a hire is not working sets out why acting early is the kinder course.
The honest limit
You will get one of the first ten wrong. Nobody's process is good enough at this sample size, with this little information and under this much time pressure, to avoid it entirely.
Treating that as a personal failure leads to two expensive behaviours. The first is hiring so slowly that the company suffers. The second is holding on to a mis-hire far too long in order to avoid admitting the error. The realistic goal is not perfection. It is a decent hit rate, and a fast and humane correction when it goes wrong.
| Unrealistic goal | Realistic goal |
|---|---|
| Never make a hiring mistake | A decent hit rate across the first ten |
| Wait until you are certain | Hold the bar, then decide quickly |
| Protect the hire from hard news | Say so early, clearly and kindly |
Everything else in this series is built for the realistic column rather than for the unattainable one.
A short list to carry into your first role
- I know the one thing most limiting us this quarter.
- I have confirmed a hire is the best way to remove it.
- I can describe what will exist after ninety days if this goes well.
- I know whether I need a generalist or a specialist.
- I have written down what a clear yes and a clear no look like.
- Someone else has a copy and will hold me to it.
If a line cannot be ticked, that is your next task, and it is a better use of the week than another conversation with a candidate.
Frequently asked questions
Is hiring really a selling problem?
At this stage it is at least as much a selling problem as an evaluation problem. You are offering unproven work, often for less cash than a candidate could earn elsewhere, so the people most worth hiring are the ones with the most alternatives.
What is the biggest cost of a weak early hire?
The salary is the smallest part. The larger costs are the founder attention spent managing the situation, the work that must be redone, the effect on strong people who notice and recalibrate, and the months before you accept what you already knew.
Can a hire be the wrong answer to the problem?
Yes. Sometimes the better answer is a contractor, a tool, a process change or a reallocation of your own time. Finding that out before opening a role is a legitimate result, even though founders rarely consider it once they have started thinking about a position.
What if I make a mistake anyway?
Expect to. One of the first ten will probably be wrong, and the aim is to notice early and correct kindly rather than to avoid the error completely.
The full method, with the checklists, is in The First Ten Hires Playbook, a free 33-page playbook.