Participating Preferred Stock Explained: Full vs Capped
Participating preferred stock explained with euro examples. Compare full, capped and non-participating payouts at four sale prices and know what to ask for.
Participating preferred stock lets an investor take a liquidation preference first and then share in the rest of the sale proceeds as well. Founders call this the "double dip", because the investor is paid twice from the same sale.
It is one of the terms in a term sheet (the short document that sets out the main terms of an investment before the contracts are written) that costs founders the most money in a mid-sized sale. This guide defines the three versions you will meet, runs the same four sale prices through each of them in euros, and lists what to ask for when an investor proposes participation.
Participating preferred stock explained in three versions
Preferred stock is a class of shares that carries extra rights over the common shares that founders usually hold. One of those rights is the liquidation preference, which says the investor is paid a set amount first when the company is sold or closed. Participation is the answer to a second question. After the investor has taken the preference, does the investor also share in what is left?
A widely used model term sheet from the US National Venture Capital Association offers three answers, and most deals use one of them.
- Non-participating. The investor gets the preference, or what the shares would receive if converted into common shares, whichever is greater. The investor never takes both.
- Full participation. The investor gets the preference first, and then the preferred shares share the remainder with the common shares, in proportion to ownership, on an as-converted basis. There is no limit on the total.
- Capped participation. The investor gets the preference and then shares in the remainder, but only until the investor has received a stated multiple of the original purchase price in total. The multiple counts the preference too.
A law-firm guide to the Middle East venture market describes the full version as a "double-dip" and says non-participating preferences are often called "downside only" protection, because they matter only when the sale price is low.
Worked example: the same four sale prices, three versions
Example. A venture investor puts €2,000,000 into new preferred shares and receives 20 percent of the company. The founders own the other 80 percent. The investor has a 1x liquidation preference, so the first €2,000,000 of any sale goes to the investor. In the capped version, the investor's total is capped at 3x, which is €6,000,000. There is no option pool, no debt and no fee, to keep the arithmetic clear.
We assume the investor can convert the preferred shares into common shares and take 20 percent of the sale price if that pays more. Check that your own terms say this.
Non-participating
- €6,000,000 sale. Preference €2,000,000, or 20% × €6,000,000 = €1,200,000 if converted. The investor takes €2,000,000.
- €20,000,000 sale. Preference €2,000,000, or 20% × €20,000,000 = €4,000,000 if converted. The investor converts and takes €4,000,000.
- €30,000,000 sale. Converted value is 20% × €30,000,000 = €6,000,000, which beats €2,000,000. The investor takes €6,000,000.
- €40,000,000 sale. Converted value is 20% × €40,000,000 = €8,000,000. The investor takes €8,000,000.
Full participation
- €6,000,000 sale. The investor takes €2,000,000 first. The remaining €4,000,000 is shared, so the investor adds 20% × €4,000,000 = €800,000. Total €2,800,000.
- €20,000,000 sale. €2,000,000 first. The remaining €18,000,000 is shared, so the investor adds 20% × €18,000,000 = €3,600,000. Total €5,600,000.
- €30,000,000 sale. €2,000,000 first. The remaining €28,000,000 gives the investor 20% × €28,000,000 = €5,600,000. Total €7,600,000.
- €40,000,000 sale. €2,000,000 first. The remaining €38,000,000 gives the investor 20% × €38,000,000 = €7,600,000. Total €9,600,000.
Capped participation at 3x (€6,000,000 in total)
- €6,000,000 and €20,000,000 sales. The participating totals are €2,800,000 and €5,600,000. Both are below the €6,000,000 cap, so the result matches full participation.
- €30,000,000 sale. Participation would pay €7,600,000, but the cap limits it to €6,000,000. Converting also pays 20% × €30,000,000 = €6,000,000. The investor takes €6,000,000.
- €40,000,000 sale. The cap limits participation to €6,000,000, but converting pays 20% × €40,000,000 = €8,000,000. The investor converts and takes €8,000,000.
| Sale price | Non-participating: investor / founders | Full participation: investor / founders | Capped at 3x: investor / founders |
|---|---|---|---|
| €6,000,000 | €2,000,000 / €4,000,000 | €2,800,000 / €3,200,000 | €2,800,000 / €3,200,000 |
| €20,000,000 | €4,000,000 / €16,000,000 | €5,600,000 / €14,400,000 | €5,600,000 / €14,400,000 |
| €30,000,000 | €6,000,000 / €24,000,000 | €7,600,000 / €22,400,000 | €6,000,000 / €24,000,000 |
| €40,000,000 | €8,000,000 / €32,000,000 | €9,600,000 / €30,400,000 | €8,000,000 / €32,000,000 |
Founder amounts are the sale price minus the investor's amount, because the founders hold all the other shares.
What the table shows
Full participation never stops costing the founders. The investor always takes the €2,000,000 preference, and then 20 percent of everything else. At €40,000,000 the founders give up €1,600,000 compared with the non-participating deal, and the difference is the €2,000,000 preference minus the investor's own 20 percent of it, which is €1,600,000.
A cap changes the result at higher prices. In this example, participation reaches the cap when €2,000,000 + 20% × (price − €2,000,000) equals €6,000,000, which is at a sale price of €22,000,000. Between €22,000,000 and €30,000,000 the investor receives a flat €6,000,000. Above €30,000,000 the investor is better off converting, and from there the capped deal and the non-participating deal pay the same. The cap therefore protects founders in the mid-range sales, and a lower cap protects them over a wider range.
How the multiple changes the picture
Participation and the multiple work together. Take the same investor and the same €6,000,000 sale, but with a 2x preference and full participation. The investor takes 2 × €2,000,000 = €4,000,000 first. The remaining €2,000,000 is shared, so the investor adds 20% × €2,000,000 = €400,000. The investor receives €4,400,000 and the founders receive €1,600,000. With a 1x non-participating preference, the same sale pays the founders €4,000,000. Two terms that each look small in a term sheet can move €2,400,000 between you and the investor in this example.
In a very low sale the terms stop mattering, because the preference swallows the whole price. At a €2,000,000 sale, a 1x investor takes everything under all three versions, and the founders receive €0.
Why investors ask for participation
Participation raises the investor's return in every sale below the price where conversion would pay more. An investor who buys 20 percent of a company is protected against a modest sale by the preference, and participation adds to that protection. When you compare offers, compare the sale-price table above for each offer and not only the valuation, because two offers with the same valuation can pay founders very different amounts.
Participation adds up when you raise again. Each new round with a participating preference takes its own first slice, and the slices are paid in the order of the ranking. Founders then share only what is left after every preference. The effect on the share you actually keep is related to equity dilution, but it works at the sale, not at the round.
What to ask for when an investor proposes participation
- Ask for non-participating first. The same law-firm guide notes that non-participating is the more common approach.
- Ask for a cap if participation stays. The model term sheet leaves the cap multiple blank, so the number is negotiable. Read whether the cap includes the preference.
- Check the conversion right. Confirm the investor can convert to common shares and what happens at the cap.
- Check the multiple. A 2x preference with full participation costs far more than 1x.
- Model your own numbers. Run the offers at three sale prices, as in the example, and check what the founders receive. Our guide to the cap table shows how to keep the share counts you need.
Frequently asked questions
What is the difference between participating and non-participating preferred stock?
A non-participating investor takes the preference or the converted share, whichever is larger. A participating investor takes the preference and then also takes a share of the remainder. At a €20,000,000 sale in the example, that is €4,000,000 against €5,600,000 for the same investor.
What does capped participation mean?
The investor shares in the remainder only until the investor's total reaches a set multiple of the original price. In the model term sheet, the total includes the preference. After the cap, the investor stops participating, although the investor may convert to common shares if that pays more.
Is participating preferred stock common?
A law-firm guide on venture terms describes non-participating as the more common approach, so participation is usually a term you negotiate. This guide does not quote a percentage, because none could be verified. Ask your lawyer what is usual in your market and round.
Does participation matter if my company becomes very valuable?
It matters at every price if the participation is uncapped, because the investor always takes the preference first. With a cap, it stops mattering once the sale price is high enough that conversion pays more, which is above €30,000,000 in the example.
Can founders negotiate participation away?
Yes. Participation, the cap and the multiple are terms in the term sheet, and they are negotiated like price. Compare offers on what the founders receive at several sale prices, and talk it through with a lawyer before you sign.
This is general education, not legal or tax advice. Instrument names, tax treatment of equity and the formalities of issuing shares differ by country. Check the details with a lawyer where your company is registered.
FIKR Cap is the cap table tool we are building at FIKR. Join the waiting list.