Home/Blog/Early Hiring/Do Reference Checks Properly, Including …
Early Hiring

Do Reference Checks Properly, Including Off-List Ones

How to do reference checks: ask specific questions, record the answers, and speak to at least one person who was not on the list the candidate gave you.

Cover of the FIKR Space guide: Do Reference Checks Properly, Including Off-List Ones

To do reference checks well, ask specific questions instead of general ones, and speak to at least one person the candidate did not put forward. Reference calls are usually treated as a formality, which is a waste, because done seriously they are one of the highest-yield steps in hiring.

The difference between a formality and a real check is the difference between a curated account and an accurate one. The candidate chooses who is on the list. You choose who else to call, and what to ask.

How to do reference checks that tell you something

A reference call can easily become a warm, brief exchange in which everybody says pleasant things and nothing is learned. The cure is to decide what you want to find out and ask questions that cannot be answered with a compliment.

The questions below are specific by design. Each one points at a different kind of information.

QuestionWhat it reveals
What did they actually own?The real scope of their work, as opposed to a job title or a team result
What would you have them do differently?A weakness, in the referee's own words
Would you hire them again, and for what?Whether the endorsement is real, and what kind of role it fits
Who else worked closely with them?A route to a person who was not on the list

None of these is clever. They work because they ask for specifics, and specifics are harder to fake than praise.

Start with what they owned

People talk about shared work in the plural. A successful result belonged to a team, and the referee may describe it warmly without saying which part was this person's. Asking what they actually owned pulls the account apart, so that you hear about the individual and not the group.

Connect the answer to the role. In how to write a ninety day role outcome you described what the new person will own. Compare that with what the referee says this person has owned before. The gap, or the match, is useful in itself.

Free guide, 33 pages: The First Ten Hires Playbook. Send me the guide.

Ask for the thing they would change

The question about doing something differently invites a weakness without asking the referee to criticise. It is easier to answer, and the answer is often more candid than a direct request for flaws would produce.

Listen to how the answer is given as well as to what it says. A thoughtful, specific response suggests the referee knows the person well. A vague or hurried one may mean the relationship was thin, or that there is something they would rather not discuss. Neither reading is proof, so treat them as prompts for a further question.

The most telling question

Would you hire them again, and for what? The second half matters as much as the first. A yes with a clear description of the kind of work tells you where the person shines. A yes that cannot say for what is a weaker endorsement than it first sounds.

It also helps you judge fit against your own generalist or specialist choice. If you decided the role needs range and the referee describes someone excellent at one narrow thing, that tells you something. The earlier decision is explained in generalist vs specialist hire.

Find someone who was not on the list

This is the step that makes the biggest difference and is the one most often skipped. Find someone who was not on the provided list, such as a former colleague you can reach through your own network, and have a genuine conversation.

This is not distrust. Candidates naturally offer people who will speak well of them, and that is a sensible thing to do. An off-list call is the difference between a curated account and an accurate one, and it is where most of the avoidable mis-hires would have been caught.

SourceStrengthLimit
Referees the candidate choseKnow the person and can answer detailed questionsSelected to be favourable
Someone they pointed you towards, such as a close colleagueWorked closely with the candidate and was recommended by a refereeMay still be a friendly source
Someone found through your own networkNot chosen by the candidateMay know the person less well, so ask what they directly saw

Use all three where you can. The point is not to catch anyone out. It is to build a picture from more than one angle.

How to conduct the off-list call

Be straightforward about why you are calling and ask the same specific questions. Keep it a conversation and not an interrogation. Ask what they directly saw, because that keeps the answer anchored to experience and away from reputation.

Take care with how you use what you hear. A single comment is one person's view. The point of speaking to several people is to see whether a pattern appears, and the next section explains what to do when one does.

When something comes up twice

If the same point appears in two conversations, follow it up instead of explaining it away. This is the discipline that separates a real check from a ritual. It is tempting to find a reason why a worrying remark does not apply, especially when the candidate is someone you like and the seat has been empty for weeks.

Put the point to the candidate directly and listen to the answer. A good explanation may settle it. Avoid the habit of accepting a convenient story. If doubt remains, the rule from the start of the process applies: a hire you are unsure about is a hire you will be unsure about for a year, and ambiguity means no.

Prepare before you pick up the phone

A good call is mostly decided in the preparation. Before each one, reread the outcome you wrote for the role and note the two or three things that matter most. Then decide which of your standard questions bear on those things, and add one follow-up for each.

It is also worth writing down, beforehand, what would worry you. If you agree in advance what a clear no would look like, you are far less likely to talk yourself out of a concern when it arrives. The bar you set before meeting anyone applies to references just as it applies to interviews.

Keep the same core set of questions for every candidate, so that you can compare what different referees say about different people. Consistency is what turns a collection of friendly conversations into evidence.

FIKR People, team and HR for founders: hiring, onboarding and reviews in one workspace. See FIKR People.

What to do with the results

Reference calls do not produce a score. They produce a picture, and the picture needs to be set beside everything else you know: the paid task, the answers to your shared questions and the views of the team members who met the candidate.

  1. List what the referees said that matches what you saw yourself.
  2. List anything that contradicts it, and anything that came up twice.
  3. Follow up each contradiction, with the candidate if need be.
  4. Judge against the bar you wrote in advance, and let ambiguity mean no.

Where the references agree with your own observation, you can proceed with more confidence. Where they disagree, that is the most valuable information the process has given you, and it is worth the awkward extra conversation.

Why this step pays for itself

A weak hire costs far more than the salary. It consumes founder attention, forces work to be redone, affects the strong people who notice and quietly recalibrate, and takes months before you accept what you already knew. A small number of extra calls is trivial next to that.

The cost is also easy to see in advance, and the benefit is easy to miss, because a mis-hire avoided leaves no trace. That is exactly why founders skip the step. The discipline is to do it anyway, treating each avoided problem as invisible evidence that the process is working.

Write it down as you go

Take notes during each call, as you do in interviews, because memory reshapes itself towards whoever you liked. Record the question and the answer, and keep the notes for each candidate in the same shape so they can be compared.

Notes also help later. After a hire has been in the job for some time, you can look back at what the referees said and ask whether it was borne out. That review is part of building each hire on evidence from the last. It is how your own process improves over ten hires instead of repeating itself.

Fit references into a fast process

References take time, and a strong candidate does not wait. Plan the calls early, line up the off-list conversation while other steps are running and keep the whole process moving. How to hire fast as a startup covers why speed matters and how to keep it without cutting the checks that count.

Free guide, 33 pages: The First Ten Hires Playbook. Send me the guide.

Common mistakes

  • Treating the call as a formality. A pleasant exchange teaches you nothing.
  • Asking general questions. General questions get general answers.
  • Calling only the listed names. You will hear only the curated account.
  • Explaining away a repeated concern. If it came up twice, follow it up.
  • Relying on memory. Write notes during the call.
FIKR People, team and HR for founders: hiring, onboarding and reviews in one workspace. See FIKR People.

Frequently asked questions

Are reference checks worth the time?

Yes, if done seriously. They are one of the highest-yield steps in hiring, and the off-list call in particular is where many avoidable mis-hires would have been caught.

Whom should I call besides the listed referees?

Someone who was not on the provided list, for example a former colleague you can reach through your own network. Ask a referee who else worked closely with the candidate, and use your own contacts as well.

What is the single best question?

Ask whether they would hire the person again, and for what. It tests both the strength of the endorsement and the kind of work the person suits.

Is calling someone off the list a sign of distrust?

No. It is the difference between a curated account and an accurate one, and it is a normal part of a careful process.

The full method, with the checklists, is in The First Ten Hires Playbook, a free 33-page playbook.

LG

Luis Goncalves

// Founder & CEO at FIKR Space

Three-time founder. Built and exited Evolution4All before this. Now building FIKR Space — the operating infrastructure underneath every innovation ecosystem (startups, accelerators, governments, investors). Lisbon-based, works global.

Claim your founding member spot.

Every founding member is hand-reviewed. Tell us who you are and how you want to co-create — we get back inside 48 hours.

Role
Job Title
Country
Cookies

We use cookies.

Essential ones keep the site working. The rest only run if you say so. No dark patterns, no pre-ticked boxes.Privacy policy

Co-create with us. It's about building it together.Co-Create With Us