Home/Blog/Angel Investing/How to Keep an Angel Investing Decision …
Angel Investing

How to Keep an Angel Investing Decision Journal

How to keep an angel investing decision journal: write what you saw, why you decided and what would change your mind, then read it when the outcome arrives.

Cover of the FIKR Space guide: How to Keep an Angel Investing Decision Journal

To keep an angel investing decision journal, write a few lines at the moment of each decision: what you saw, why you said yes or no, what would change your mind and what you expect to have happened in two years. Then read it later, when the outcome arrives, and compare it with what you believed.

Angel investing gives you very little feedback. Decisions are few, outcomes take years and nobody grades your reasoning along the way. The journal is the feedback loop you have to build yourself, and it is the cheapest improvement available to you.

How to keep an angel investing decision journal: write it at the moment you decide

The rule that matters most is timing. Write the entry on the day you make the call, before you know how it turned out. An entry written afterwards is a story, and stories flatter the person telling them.

Without a journal, you will remember your reasoning as better than it was. With one, you can separate a good call that went badly from a poor call that went well. That distinction is the whole point. In a field where a few outcomes carry the result and luck plays a large part, the only way to learn from your own judgement is to record it before luck gets involved.

The four things to write down

Keep the entry short enough that you will actually write it. Four prompts are enough.

PromptWhat to writeWhy it helps later
What did I see?The facts in front of you: the founders, the product, the stage, what you checkedShows what information you actually had at the time
Why yes or no?The real reason, in your own wordsSeparates a considered reason from a mood
What would change my mind?The evidence that would turn a no into a yes, or the reverseGives you a clear test the next time the company comes back
What do I expect in two years?A plain description of where you think the company will beGives you something to compare with the outcome

A few honest lines on each is better than a page on one. If you cannot answer the third prompt, that is useful to know. It usually means the decision rests on a feeling you have not yet examined.

Free guide, 26 pages: The Business Angel Playbook. Send me the guide.

Write down the passes, not only the yeses

Most of the companies you look at, you will not back. If the journal only holds investments, it tells you about a small and unrepresentative part of your judgement. A pass is also a decision, and some of them will turn out to be mistakes.

A short entry for each pass takes a few minutes and gives you something rare: a record of what you rejected and why. Years later you can ask whether your reasons for saying no held up. That is how you find out whether your screen is too strict, too loose or biased towards a type of founder you simply feel comfortable with. If you are still building your screen, how to evaluate a startup pitch sets out the questions worth asking before you write the entry.

Set the follow-on rule before you are asked

The journal is also the right place to write down your rule for follow-on money, and to do it before a company you backed raises again. When that moment comes there is usually a deadline, and it arrives when you are least able to think clearly.

Write down what would make you put in more: evidence that the company has done what it said, a price you are comfortable with and money left in your reserve. Write down what you will do if the next round is priced lower than yours, which is uncomfortable and common. Then treat each follow-on as a fresh decision, using the same screen as the first time. It protects you from sending good money after a story you have grown attached to.

Keep it beside your pipeline

A journal and a pipeline do different jobs. The pipeline tells you what you owe each company next. The journal tells you why you decided what you did. Keep them together, because a note in the pipeline is much more useful when it links to the reasoning behind it.

A simple set of stages is enough: watching, due diligence, contacted, meeting scheduled, then invested or passed. For each company, keep a private note, the reason you are where you are and a date to follow up. The detail is in how to track startup deals. A spreadsheet does this adequately. The discipline matters more than the tool.

Read it, on a schedule

A journal you never read is a diary. Put two dates in your calendar.

  • When an outcome arrives. Open the original entry and compare it with what happened. Did the facts you listed turn out to be the important ones? Did the thing you said would change your mind actually appear?
  • Once a year. List every company, what you put in, what has changed and what you decided not to follow up on and why. Compare it against your original loss limit, your thesis and your rules.

The yearly review takes an afternoon, and it is where the practice becomes a craft. It is the only moment in the cycle when you look at the result of your own judgement as a whole. Ask what you would do differently and what the journal shows about which of your instincts held up. If the answer after a year or two is that angel investing is not for you, that is a useful result, reached at a cost you chose in advance.

FIKR Investors, for business angels: watch founders pitch and back the ones you believe in. See FIKR Investors.

Mistakes that make the journal useless

MistakeWhat it does to you
Writing the entry after the outcome is knownTurns a record of your judgement into a justification of it
Recording only the investmentsHides the passes, which are most of your decisions
Vague reasons such as "strong team"Gives you nothing to test later
Never reading itRemoves the only feedback loop you have
Using paper value as the verdictA price set by the last round is not what you could sell for

The last row deserves a note. A valuation set by a recent round tells you what the last investor paid, not what you could sell for. Keep a clear distinction between value on paper and money in your account, and plan as though the money is locked and may be lost. This is part of being honest in the journal.

What the journal cannot do

A journal does not make a bad investment good, and it does not make the asset safe. Angel investing is not a reliable way to make money. Skilled, experienced investors lose money on many of their bets, and no method removes that. What the journal does is more modest: it keeps you from repeating avoidable mistakes, and it makes sure you learn something along the way.

It also fits with the rest of the habits that make an angel useful to founders. The post on how to be a good angel investor covers the behaviour that founders remember, and a journal helps you stay consistent about it.

Free guide, 26 pages: The Business Angel Playbook. Send me the guide.

A one-page template you can copy

  • Date and company.
  • Decision. Yes, no or not yet.
  • What I saw. The facts, the stage, what I checked.
  • Why. The real reason, in plain words.
  • What would change my mind.
  • What I expect in two years.
  • Follow-up date.

Keep every entry in the same place and in the same order, so that you can read ten of them in a row and notice patterns.

FIKR Investors, for business angels: watch founders pitch and back the ones you believe in. See FIKR Investors.

Frequently asked questions

How long should an entry be?

A few lines per prompt is enough. If it takes more than a few minutes you will stop doing it. A short entry written on the day beats a thorough one you never write.

Do I need special software?

No. A document or a spreadsheet works well. What matters is that entries are dated, kept in one place and easy to find when an outcome arrives.

Should I write entries for companies I did not back?

Yes. Passes are most of your decisions, and some of them will be mistakes. A short note on why you passed is how you learn whether your screen is working.

What if the journal shows my judgement is poor?

That is a useful result. You learn it at a cost you chose in advance, and you can change your screen, make smaller investments or decide that angel investing is not for you.

This is general education, not investment, legal or tax advice. Investing in startups is risky and you can lose all the money you invest. Rules for who may invest, and how investments are taxed, differ by country, so check where you live.

FIKR Investors is a place for business angels to watch founder pitches and keep a private deal pipeline. See FIKR Investors.

LG

Luis Goncalves

// Founder & CEO at FIKR Space

Three-time founder. Built and exited Evolution4All before this. Now building FIKR Space — the operating infrastructure underneath every innovation ecosystem (startups, accelerators, governments, investors). Lisbon-based, works global.

Claim your founding member spot.

Every founding member is hand-reviewed. Tell us who you are and how you want to co-create — we get back inside 48 hours.

Role
Job Title
Country
Cookies

We use cookies.

Essential ones keep the site working. The rest only run if you say so. No dark patterns, no pre-ticked boxes.Privacy policy

Co-create with us. It's about building it together.Co-Create With Us