Home/Blog/Angel Investing/How to Be a Good Angel Investor Beyond t…
Angel Investing

How to Be a Good Angel Investor Beyond the Money

How to be a good angel investor beyond the money: add contacts and mentoring, decide with speed and clarity, say no kindly and avoid interfering with founders.

Cover of the FIKR Space guide: How to Be a Good Angel Investor Beyond the Money

To be a good angel investor beyond the money, give founders what a cheque cannot buy, which is useful introductions, honest and timely answers, and advice offered when asked. Then step back and let the founders run the company.

Founders can usually find money somewhere. What they often lack is time, contacts and someone experienced who will tell them the truth. This post covers what angels can add, how to make decisions quickly and clearly, how to say no with care, and how to avoid the habits that make founders dread an investor's email. None of it makes an investment safe. Startup investing is risky and you can lose all the money you invest.

How to be a good angel investor: what a cheque does not give

A cheque gives a company runway, which is time to build before the money runs out. It does not give direction, introductions or confidence. Those come from people, and a founder who has several offers will often choose the investor they would like to work with.

There is some research behind the idea that this non-financial part matters. In a 2010 NBER working paper, the economists William Kerr, Josh Lerner and Antoinette Schoar studied ventures that applied to two angel groups. Ventures just above the funding line were more likely to survive than similar ventures just below it. The authors suggest that the angels' mentoring and networks of business contacts "may have helped the new ventures the most". That is a hedged conclusion from one study of two groups, so use it as a prompt to think about what you offer. It promises nothing about what you will achieve.

The rest of this post turns that idea into habits you can practise.

What you can add besides money

Contacts

An introduction costs you little and can save a founder months. Think of the customers, partners, hires, lawyers and other investors you know. A good introduction is specific. It says who the founder is, what they are looking for, and why this person might care. It also gives the other person an easy way to say no. Ask the founder first which introductions would help, so you do not send them to people they do not need.

Mentoring

Mentoring means sharing what you know when the founder wants it. If you ran a business, hired a team or sold to a certain kind of customer, that experience is valuable. Offer it as one view among several, and say plainly where your knowledge ends. A founder who learns that you will say "I don't know this market" will trust you more when you do speak with confidence.

Hiring and credibility

Having a respected person on the list of investors can make it easier for a young company to hire, sell and raise its next round. Use this carefully. Never let your name be used for something you have not agreed to, and do not promise introductions you cannot deliver.

Patience and steadiness

Startups have bad months. An investor who stays calm, asks good questions and does not panic is a real asset. You will not always feel calm, and it is fine to say so privately to someone you trust. The point is to be steady with the founder.

What you can offerWhat it looks like in practiceWhat to watch for
IntroductionsA short, specific message to someone who could helpSending names the founder did not ask for
MentoringA regular call where the founder sets the topicsGiving orders instead of options
CredibilityBeing a named backer, with the founder's agreementClaims the company cannot support
SteadinessCalm replies during hard monthsPassing your own worry to the founder
Speed and clarityA clear answer by the date you gaveSilence while you "think about it"
Free guide, 26 pages: The Business Angel Playbook. Send me the guide.

Speed and clarity in your decisions

For a founder who is raising, time is money. Every week without an answer is a week of uncertainty, and a slow yes can hurt as much as a quick no. The best thing you can do for a founder you have just met is to be clear about where you stand.

  1. Say how you decide. Tell the founder what you will look at and how long it usually takes you. Two sentences are enough.
  2. Give a date. "I will give you an answer by the end of next week" is kinder than "I'll get back to you".
  3. Keep the date. If you need more time, say so before the date, and say why.
  4. Ask for what you need once. Collect your questions into one message rather than sending them one by one.
  5. Say what would change your mind. If your answer is "not yet", tell the founder what you would need to see.

A tidy record of where each company stands makes this easier. The post on how to track startup deals shows a simple way to keep it, with follow-up dates for exactly this reason.

Do your homework before the call

Founders notice whether you read what they sent. Arriving with informed questions respects their time and gets you better answers. The guides on how to evaluate a startup pitch and the due diligence checklist can help you prepare.

Saying no kindly

Most of what you see, you will decline. How you decline says a lot about you, and founders talk to one another.

  • Be prompt. A clear no after a week is better than a vague maybe after two months.
  • Be specific, and only about what you know. "I do not invest in hardware" is a fact about you. "Your market is too small" is a judgement you may be wrong about, so say it as your view.
  • Be brief and warm. Thank them for their time, give one honest reason, and wish them well.
  • Do not hand out false hope. "Keep me posted" is fine when you mean it, and unkind when you do not.
  • Remember you may be wrong. Many investors have passed on companies that later did well. A kind no leaves the door open.

Here is a short template you can edit. "Thank you for sharing the pitch and for the time on the call. I have decided not to invest at this stage, mainly because I could not get comfortable with how you plan to reach your first customers. That is my view and I may be wrong. I wish you luck, and I would be glad to see an update if that part of the plan changes."

If you keep a note of why you passed, as suggested in the pipeline post, this message takes a minute to write.

Not interfering

An angel is a minority investor who usually owns a small share of the company and does not run it. Founders carry the daily decisions and the consequences. Your role is to support them, and they stay in charge.

Habits that cause friction

  • Constant check-ins. Asking for updates every few days takes time that the founder needs to build.
  • Directing the work. Telling founders which feature to build or whom to hire, rather than offering a view when asked.
  • Making it about you. Repeating how much you invested, or what you did in your own career.
  • Contacting the team behind the founder's back. Go through the founder, unless you have agreed otherwise.
  • Disappearing. The opposite problem. Silence after the cheque tells the founder you only cared about the deal.

Agree the rhythm at the start

The simplest way to avoid friction is to talk about it before the money moves. Ask the founder how often they want to update you, in what form, and when they would like your help. Write down what you agree, and treat it as a starting point you can revisit. If you are unsure which rights you will have, ask the questions in SAFE vs convertible note for investors before you sign.

FIKR Investors, for business angels: watch founders pitch and back the ones you believe in. See FIKR Investors.

How founders experience investors

Founders talk to each other, and they remember how investors behaved when things were hard. These are the things they often hope for.

  • A fast, clear answer, even when it is no.
  • An investor who understands that early plans change.
  • Questions that show the investor read the material.
  • Help when asked, and room when not.
  • Honesty when something goes wrong, and no blame.
  • Fair treatment in later rounds, including a clear view on whether you will invest again. If you are unsure how to think about this, see pro rata rights explained.

A useful test is to ask yourself, "Would I want to be on the other end of my own email?" If the answer is no, rewrite it.

Free guide, 26 pages: The Business Angel Playbook. Send me the guide.

A short checklist for the next conversation

  1. I read what the founder sent before the call.
  2. I told them how and when I will decide.
  3. I know which introductions I can offer, and I asked whether they would help.
  4. I will say no promptly if it is a no, with one honest reason.
  5. I agreed how often we will talk if I invest.
  6. I will not try to run the company.
FIKR Investors, for business angels: watch founders pitch and back the ones you believe in. See FIKR Investors.

Frequently asked questions

Does being a hands-on angel make an investment more likely to succeed?

No one can promise that. One 2010 NBER working paper by Kerr, Lerner and Schoar found that ventures just above the funding line at two angel groups were more likely to survive, and the authors suggested that mentoring and contacts may explain it. It is one study, and startups fail for many reasons whatever the investor does.

How much time should an angel spend helping each company?

That is for you and the founder to agree, and it depends on how much time you have. Many angels choose fewer companies so they can be useful to each. Be honest about what you can give.

Should I give feedback when I pass on a deal?

A short, honest and kind reason is usually welcome and costs little. You do not have to give detailed feedback. Say only what you are reasonably sure of, and make clear it is your own view.

What if I disagree with a founder's decision after I invest?

Say so once, clearly and privately, and explain why. Then respect that the decision belongs to the founder. If the disagreement is serious, look at the rights in your documents with a lawyer where you live.

Can I help if I have never run a company?

Yes. Contacts, customer insight, a professional skill, or a calm view from outside can all help. Say what you know and what you do not, and offer what you actually have.

This is general education, not investment, legal or tax advice. Investing in startups is risky and you can lose all the money you invest. Rules for who may invest, and how investments are taxed, differ by country, so check where you live.

FIKR Investors is a place for business angels to watch founder pitches and keep a private deal pipeline. See FIKR Investors.

LG

Luis Goncalves

// Founder & CEO at FIKR Space

Three-time founder. Built and exited Evolution4All before this. Now building FIKR Space — the operating infrastructure underneath every innovation ecosystem (startups, accelerators, governments, investors). Lisbon-based, works global.

Claim your founding member spot.

Every founding member is hand-reviewed. Tell us who you are and how you want to co-create — we get back inside 48 hours.

Role
Job Title
Country
Cookies

We use cookies.

Essential ones keep the site working. The rest only run if you say so. No dark patterns, no pre-ticked boxes.Privacy policy

Co-create with us. It's about building it together.Co-Create With Us