SAFE vs Convertible Note for Investors: What You Sign
SAFE vs convertible note for investors: learn what each one gives you and what it does not, how cap and discount work for you, and what to ask before signing.
A SAFE and a convertible note both let you give a startup money now and receive shares later, but a note is a loan with interest and a maturity date, while a SAFE is neither a loan nor a share. In both cases you own no shares on the day you send the money, and you have no vote.
This post takes the investor's side of the two instruments. It shows what each one gives you, what it does not, how a cap and a discount work from where you sit, and what to ask before you sign. A short worked example at the end shows the arithmetic, including what happens if no funding round ever comes. The founder's side is in the guides on SAFE notes and convertible notes.
SAFE vs convertible note for investors: what each one gives you
Both instruments exist because early on, nobody can say what a startup is worth. Rather than argue about a price today, you and the founder agree on how your money will turn into shares when a later round sets a price. Until then, you hold a contract, not shares.
What a SAFE gives you
A SAFE is a Simple Agreement for Future Equity, created by Y Combinator. It gives you the right to receive shares if and when the company sells shares in a priced round, on the terms written in the document. It carries no interest and has no maturity date, so nothing falls due on a set day. It is also not debt, so you cannot demand your money back the way a lender can.
What a convertible note gives you
A convertible note is a loan that is meant to convert into shares. You are a lender, the loan earns interest, and it has a maturity date on which it falls due. If the company raises a qualifying round before then, the loan and usually its interest convert into shares. If it does not, the note has to be repaid, extended or converted on terms the contract sets. In some countries the same thing is called a convertible loan.
What neither gives you
This is the part newer angels overlook. Until conversion, neither instrument gives you
- shares, so you are not yet on the share register;
- a vote at the shareholders' meeting;
- any assurance of an outcome, since the company may never raise a priced round or may fail.
Startup investing is risky and you can lose all the money you invest. A note's interest and a SAFE's cap and discount only change how many shares you might get. They do not make the money safer.
| Question | SAFE | Convertible note |
|---|---|---|
| What is it legally? | A contract to receive shares later; not a loan | A loan that can convert into shares |
| Interest? | None | Yes, set in the note |
| Maturity date? | None | Yes, the day it falls due |
| Do I hold shares now? | No | No |
| Do I have a vote now? | No | No |
| Can I demand repayment? | Not as a lender | Possibly at maturity, if the contract allows |
| Cap and discount? | Possible | Possible |
Cap and discount from the investor's side
These two terms decide how many shares your money turns into. Founders see them as dilution. You see them as the reward for going early.
The valuation cap
The cap is the highest company valuation used to convert your money. If the next round values the company above the cap, you still convert as if it were worth only the cap, so you get more shares for each euro. If the next round values it below the cap, the cap does nothing for you. A lower cap is better for you and worse for the founders. Ask whether the cap is pre-money or post-money, because the same number gives you a different percentage in each version, as the SAFE guide shows.
The discount
A discount gives you a lower share price than the new investors in the round pay. A 20 percent discount means you convert at 80 percent of the round price. It helps you whatever the valuation turns out to be. When an instrument has both a cap and a discount, the usual rule is that you take whichever gives the lower price per share.
Interest on a note
On a note, interest usually adds to the amount that converts, so you receive more shares. Ask whether it is simple or compounding, and whether it is paid in cash or added to the principal.
Dilution after you convert
Your percentage will shrink when the company later sells more shares or enlarges its option pool. That is normal. The guide on equity dilution explains it, and pro rata rights explain the right some investors negotiate to keep their share.
What to ask before you sign
These are questions to put to the founder and to a lawyer who knows the law where you live. The answers shape what you hold.
- Is the cap pre-money or post-money? Ask for the percentage you would hold at the cap, written down.
- Is there a discount, a cap, both, or neither? An instrument with neither leaves you with no price protection unless it has a most favoured nation clause.
- What converts it, and when? Ask what counts as a qualifying round, and whether a small round triggers conversion.
- What happens if no round comes? For a note, ask what happens on the maturity date. For a SAFE, ask what you receive if the company is sold or closes.
- How are other SAFEs and notes handled? Many of them together can take a large share before the round. Ask to see the list.
- Do I get any information rights? Ask whether you will receive updates, and how often.
- Do I get pro rata rights? Ask whether you may invest in later rounds to keep your share.
- Which law governs the document, and does the instrument fit the company's country? A SAFE was written for US companies, and other countries use other tools.
Rules for who may invest and how the result is taxed differ by country. Check them where you live before you commit.
Worked example for an investor
Example. The numbers are made up to show the arithmetic. A company's two founders hold 2,000,000 shares and nobody else holds any. You invest €30,000. The company later raises a priced round in which new investors put in €3,000,000 at €6.00 per share. There is no option pool and no other SAFE or note, to keep it simple.
Case A, a post-money SAFE with a €6,000,000 cap and no discount
- Your percentage before the round. €30,000 ÷ €6,000,000 = 0.5 percent.
- Your shares. They must make up 0.5 percent of all shares once added, so S ÷ (2,000,000 + S) = 0.005, which gives S = about 10,050 shares. Check the price. €6,000,000 ÷ 2,010,050 = about €2.985 per share, and 10,050 × €2.985 = about €30,000.
- Compare the prices. The round price is €6.00, higher than €2.985, so the cap applies.
- New investors. €3,000,000 ÷ €6.00 = 500,000 shares.
- Total shares. 2,000,000 + 10,050 + 500,000 = 2,510,050.
- Your percentage after the round. 10,050 ÷ 2,510,050 = about 0.40 percent. It is lower than 0.5 percent because the new shares dilute everyone.
Case B, a note with 8 percent simple interest, a 15 percent discount and no cap
The note converts after 12 months.
- Interest. €30,000 × 8% × 1 year = €2,400. The amount that converts is €32,400.
- Discount price. €6.00 × (1 − 0.15) = €5.10 per share.
- Your shares. €32,400 ÷ €5.10 = 6,352.9, rounded to 6,353 shares.
- Total shares. 2,000,000 + 6,353 + 500,000 = 2,506,353.
- Your percentage after the round. 6,353 ÷ 2,506,353 = about 0.25 percent.
| Instrument | Money in | Shares | Share of the company after the round |
|---|---|---|---|
| SAFE, €6,000,000 post-money cap | €30,000 | 10,050 | about 0.40% |
| Note, 8% interest, 15% discount, no cap | €30,000 (€32,400 with interest) | 6,353 | about 0.25% |
The SAFE gave more shares here because its cap price was far below the round price, while the discount on the note only moves the price a little. A different cap or discount would reverse the order. Neither instrument is better in general. You can only compare two offers by running the numbers on each.
On paper, 10,050 shares at €6.00 are worth €60,300 and 6,353 shares are worth €38,118. Those are values on paper at one round price. They are not money in your account, and you cannot sell the shares just because the company set a price.
If no round ever comes
Suppose the company never raises a priced round.
- The SAFE. Nothing falls due. It stays open until a priced round, a sale or a shutdown. You have no interest and no right to be repaid on a date. What you receive in a sale or shutdown depends on the terms of the document you signed.
- The note. At 24 months, interest of €30,000 × 8% × 2 = €4,800 has built up, so €34,800 is due. You may be able to ask for repayment, or agree to extend, or convert at a price fixed in the note. But a company with no new round often has no cash, and a claim on a company that cannot pay is worth little.
In both cases, you could lose the whole €30,000. The interest on the note does not change that risk.
Frequently asked questions
Is a SAFE safer for an investor than a convertible note?
No instrument makes a startup investment safe. A note gives you interest and a maturity date, which may give you a way to push for repayment. A SAFE gives you neither. Which suits you better depends on the terms and on the company.
Do I own shares when I sign a SAFE or a note?
No. You own a contract. You become a shareholder only when the instrument converts, and until then you have no vote.
Is the interest on a convertible note paid to me in cash?
Often it is added to the principal and converts into shares, but the contract decides. Ask whether it is simple or compounding and whether any of it is paid in cash.
What if the SAFE has no cap and no discount?
Then you convert at the same price as the new investors, with no reward for going early, unless the document has a most favoured nation clause. Read the document closely and ask a lawyer where you live.
Which should I choose as an angel?
That is your decision, and this post cannot make it for you. Founders usually offer one instrument, and your choice is whether to accept those terms. Compare them with a worked example like the one above, and read how to start angel investing if you are new.
This is general education, not investment, legal or tax advice. Investing in startups is risky and you can lose all the money you invest. Rules for who may invest, and how investments are taxed, differ by country, so check where you live.
FIKR Investors is a place for business angels to watch founder pitches and keep a private deal pipeline. See FIKR Investors.